Best Toddler Pillows – Ensure Sweet Dreams for Your Child

Baby Gear

Best Toddler Pillows

Image: Abigail Batchelder

With more than 91% of Americans going to bed with a pillow, and 27% using at least three pillows every night, chances are excellent that your child will soon be enjoying all of the benefits that a pillow can offer. This includes:

  • Falling asleep faster​
  • Staying asleep through the night
  • Enjoying the companionship of a soft and comfortable friend
  • Feeling more adult-like at bedtime

So if your child is at least 1 1/2 to 2 years old, it may be time to invest in a child’s pillow.

You certainly have choices, but please don’t consider the unsanitary option of handing down a used pillow from an older family member. Spending a few dollars on a new pillow is an excellent investment for you and your child, while keeping her happy, safe, and comfortable.

“I am so stressed out because my child slept through the night for a full nine hours,” said no parent ever. That’s why choosing among the best toddler pillows available will make both you and your toddler rest easier.

Is now the right time?

Before you go any further, let’s make sure that now is the right time for you to invest in a toddler pillow. Here are some questions to consider:

  • Is she at least 1 1/2 years of age?​
  • Does she have shoulders at least as wide as her hips? (This provides more sleeping comfort.)
  • Is the child using a stuffed animal or blanket as a makeshift pillow?
  • Does he actively seek out the pillows of parents or older siblings?

If you answered ‘yes’ to the first question—and to most of the last three —chances are good that your child is ready to begin enjoying a brand new toddler pillow.

Here are some things to consider as you venture off into the wild blue yonder to make your first purchase.

Finding the right pillow size

In comparison to a standard adult pillow that measures 16” x 20”, a toddler pillow is a compact, manageable and safe alternative. Unlike adult pillows, their smaller counterparts are specifically made to accommodate children’s proportions.

Pillows for toddlers also contain less fabric than adult pillows, greatly reducing the risk for suffocation. While sizes on children’s pillows will vary, they are considerably smaller than standard adult pillows and far smaller than some of the grander, oversized alternatives on the market today.

What's inside the pillow?

Before pressing the “place order” button on your computer, it will behoove you to know what exactly your pillow is made of on the inside. All filling is not the same and you need to know both the advantages and disadvantages of as many types of pillows as you can.

100% Cotton​

Pros: Young children will enjoy the breathable, soft fabric of 100% cotton filling, as well as the flatter and firmer feel of a pillow that toddlers seem to prefer.

Cons: Unfortunately, cotton does not retain its shape as well as a polyester pillow, and allergies  present more of a concern as well.​

Polyester/Polyfill

Pros: Allergies and odors are virtually eliminated with this synthetic alternative and it is more durable and holds onto its shape longer than cotton.

Cons: In general, these pillows have a softer feel that is not as firm as cotton, which can be a good or bad thing, depending on your child’s preferences; not always the cheapest alternative.

Down or Feather-Fill

Pros: Lightweight and extremely long-lasting, while providing an incredibly soft feel.

Cons: Not a great fit for toddlers due to softness, which can increase the chance of suffocation. On the dust-mite allergy scale, this one fails miserably as well.​

Latex

Pros: Excellent sleep quality, firm, and “springs” back when pressure is relieved. It's also long-lasting and dust-mite resistant.

Cons: Your toddler may become alarmed or startled with the springboard effect. Also these are a bit pricy and they don't breathe very well.

Buckwheat/Hull

Pros: Stays cool, dry and well-ventilated; conforms to contours of head and neck to provide maximum support; long-lasting.

Cons: Sometimes too firm, bordering on hard; makes crunching or crackling noises when the child changes position, possibly triggering a wake-up event (not a good thing!); can lose up to 7% of its volume each year.​

Choosing between a pillowcase and a machine-washable pillow

A machine-washable pillow generally does not come with a pillowcase, and the entire pillow can simply be tossed into the washer for the full cycle for proper cleaning. Many parents like this simple and easy option.

A pillowcase version allows the case to be cleaned in the washing machine; however, usually the pillow itself is not washable. Some parents prefer the pillowcase option because it provides an extra layer that prevents odors from penetrating the pillow. Also, a pillowcase generally dries faster than an entire pillow.

Is the pillow hypoallergenic?

A hypoallergenic pillow has many benefits, including providing antimicrobial protection from illness-causing microbes.​

Pillows without anti-microbial protection will need to be changed more often, increasing the overall long-term price of your purchase.

A hypoallergenic pillow will virtually keep your child’s pillow free from dust mites which have been known to wreak havoc on allergy sufferers.​

Is the pillow organic?

While the inside of your pillow may or may not be made of cotton, the outer part of the pillow is made of either regular or organic cotton in most cases.

Organic cotton frees your child of contact from harmful bleaches, dyes, and toxins that may be present in the routine manufacturing process. For the differences between organic cotton and regular cotton, check out this article. ​

Does the company offer a satisfaction guarantee?

You should know the answer to the following questions before you take the toddler pillow plunge:

  • If you are not satisfied with your pillow for any reason, will you be able to send it back for a full refund, or will you simply receive a credit from the merchant?​
  • Is there a reasonable amount of time to return the product after the purchase, such as 14 days or 30 days?
  • Who will pay for the shipping if you return the pillow?
  • How long will your pillow’s guarantee last?

Before we get into the nitty gritty, let's take a quick look at our top picks.

Quick comparison: Best toddler pillow​s

Pillow

Features we love

Rating

Buy it now

Angel Dreams
Toddler Pillow

Best toddler pillows

- Multiple filling options
- Hypoallergenic and washable
- 90-day money-back guarantee
- Made in the USA

Little One's Pillow

Best toddler pillows

- Hypoallergenic and
chemical-free
- Hand-crafted in the USA
- Soft organic cotton shell
- Outstanding customer service

SlumberLux
Toddler Pillow

Best Toddler Pillows

- Hypoallergenic
microfiber filling
- Made in the USA
- 1-year comfort guarantee
- Machine washable

No Pillowcase
Toddler Pillow

Best Toddler Pillows

- Allergy free
- Machine wash and dry
- Double-stitched 200-thread count percale cover
- Recommended by pediatricians
- Made in the USA

Utopia Bedding Toddler Pillow

Best Toddler Pillows

- Amazing bang for your buck
- Hypoallergenic and
machine washable
- Comes in set of 2
- Nice, fluffy and soft
but not too plush

Angel Baby Organic Toddler Pillow

Best Toddler Pillows

- Breathable and eco-friendly
- Uses memory foam
- Fabric is designed to dissipate heat
- Helps toddlers sleep at a natural angle

Clevamama ClevaFoam Toddler Pillow

Best Toddler Pillows

- Airflow draws
away moisture
- Keeps head and spine aligned correctly
- Protect's your child's head
- Breathable
and lightweight
- Comes with good
quality cover

For the full scoop on the best pillows for your toddler, keep reading!

Angel Dreams Toddler Pillow

In baseball terms, this manufacturer has just knocked one out of the park!

This pillow really rings the satisfaction meter on most criteria, including a 100% soft cotton hypoallergenic pillow cover to curtail allergy issues, a choice of firmness, a stupendous customer rating (4.6 stars out of 5), and a company that stands behind the quality of its product.

Supported by a family-operated company that produces its product in the U.S.A., this manufacturer offers a Satisfaction Guarantee that will either refund your money or provide you with a credit to purchase additional products. The choice is yours!

Best toddler pillows

When ordering, you can choose between ‘more fill’ and ‘less fill’, depending on your child's preference. If you're unhappy with your choice, the company will make it right in order to get your child the ideal pillow.

As for cleaning, simply wash your pillow on a cold, gentle cycle and dry it on low heat. These pillows, bolstered by quality polyester fillings, are built to maintain their shapes after many washings.​

Technical specs

  • Dimensions: 13 x 4 x 18
  • Weight: 3 oz. 
  • BPA-Free, Phthalate-Free
  • Recommended for ages 2-5
  • 100% soft cotton cover, hypoallergenic
  • Made in the USA

Pros

  • Great guarantee and a company that backs its product​
  • Hypoallergenic, allergy-friendly
  • Holds shape through numerous washings
  • Sky-high customer ratings

Cons

  • Could be firmer​
  • Almost too fluffy
  • Lacks organic designation

Our favorite feature

This manufacturer takes all of the risk out of purchasing a children’s pillow with an excellent Satisfaction Guarantee and a customer service team that will do everything in its power to ensure that you are 100% pleased with the purchase. The stellar ratings from satisfied customers will make you feel confident that you are dealing with a top-notch company.​


Little One’s Pillow

While it’s an exciting journey choosing your toddler’s first pillow, you will want to make sure that you are choosing a quality product that will suit her needs for years to come. This quality, handcrafted pillow was produced with great attention to detail and provides everything you're looking for and more.

It offers a “USDA-certified Organic” 100% cotton cover, which means that you can rest easy knowing that your child faces no exposure risk to harsh or caustic chemicals, since none were used during the manufacturing process.

It’s also hypoallergenic, which greatly reduces the chances of your little one coming into contact with pesky, allergy-inducing dust mites. It’s fine for washing with cold or warm water with a mild detergent.

Best toddler pillows

The product also comes with a top-notch guarantee which states that your pillow will keep its shape with no lumps for over 400 washings. If you are not satisfied with your purchase for any reason, you can simply send it back for a full refund for UP TO ONE FULL YEAR with no questions asked! And with a 4.9/5-star online customer service rating, you can feel confident that this company will stand by and live up to its guarantee.​

Technical specs

  • Dimensions: 13 x 18 x 3
  • Weight: 6.9 oz. 
  • Recommended for ages 2+
  • Organic cotton
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Made in the USA

Pros

  • Premier Satisfaction Guarantee​
  • ​No chemicals used in manufacturing
  • Hypoallergenic, allergy-friendly
  • Near-perfect customer rating

Cons

  • Somewhat flat, but supportive​
  • Not the least expensive option

Our favorite feature

This well-built, handcrafted, quality product provides your child with the ultimate protection because it is hypoallergenic (allergy-friendly) and uses the finest organic cotton (no chemical treatment). In a nutshell, you are purchasing a top-of-the-line, natural and safe product with a Satisfaction Guarantee second to none.​


SlumberLux Toddler Pillow

Although it’s another competitor in the ‘small pillows for kids’ arena, this product is a giant in terms of overall quality, materials, and customer ratings. The company takes all the risk of out your purchase by offering a 365-day guarantee if you're dissatisfied for any reason. Your money will be refunded with no questions asked, and you won’t even be asked to return the pillow!

Best Toddler Pillows

This pillow is extremely soft because it uses the finest microfiber imported from Korea as its filling. The cover is 100% cotton and hypoallergenic, leaving you free to hand it to your child without the allergy concerns caused by dust mites. It’s easy also easy to launder – wash with warm/cold water and tumble dry on low heat. There is no pillow case included, but you can certainly buy one.​

Technical specs

  • Dimensions:13 x 18 
  • Weight: 8 oz. 
  • Recommended for ages 2+
  • 100% Cotton Cover
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Microfiber-filled
  • Made in the USA

Pros

  • Neither extremely flat nor extremely fluffy​
  • Microfiber filled for dream-like softness
  • Good value
  • 365-day guarantee

Cons

  • No organic claim
  • Not overly head-supportive

​Our favorite feature

The microfiber filling creates cloud-like softness that helps provide an excellent night’s sleep. Microfiber is not an inexpensive material to use, but the company does an excellent job of offering it to customers while keeping the price very reasonable. The end result is a pillow that’s not too flat and not too fluffy. This pillow would be the favorite choice of Baby Bear!​


No Pillowcase Toddler Pillow

While many children’s pillow manufacturers offer one color choice – white – this company offers a machine-washable pillow that comes in many other prints as well, allowing you to choose the right match for your toddler’s room. Also available is a complete line of matching pillowcases (sold separately).

Best Toddler Pillows

The polyester cluster fiber filling and 100% cotton cover provides for an allergy-free environment, free of dust mites. The pillow is strikingly soft and implements just the right amount of filling. Each one is hand-filled and not machine-blown, which provides even quality from the time it leaves the factory. The pillow does not retain heat during the night and will help your child enjoy a comfortable night’s sleep.​

Technical specs

  • Dimensions: 13 x 18 
  • Recommended for ages 2+
  • 100% Cotton Cover
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Polyester-filled
  • Made in the USA

Pros

  • Extremely soft​
  • Not overfilled, stays cool
  • Hand-filled, not hand-blown
  • Very good online ratings

Cons

  • Top of fluffy spectrum, but flattens somewhat over time​
  • No organic designation
  • Not enough info on guarantee

Our favorite feature

This children’s pillow manufacturer has become the king of the personal touch by offering a super-cute line of décor pillows to outfit your child’s room, as well as a complete line of matching toddler pillowcases. Each pillow is individually hand-filled with care to ensure consistent quality.​


Utopia Bedding Premium Quality Toddler Pillow 

If you’re looking for a little pillow but also want a gigantic bargain, this product may be the ideal one for you and your child.

You definitely won’t have to dig very deep into your wallet to get not ONE, but TWO soft supportive pillows for your child at a phenomenal price. Besides the exceptional value, this pillow is 100% cotton, hypoallergenic, and is about the same size as most other toddler pillows. Parents will love this durability of this pillow as well as the peace-of-mind in knowing that their children will be free from allergy-causing dust mites.

Best Toddler Pillows

Technical specs

  • Dimensions: 13 x 18 x 3
  • Weight: 10.4 oz. per pillow
  • Recommended for ages 2+
  • 100% Cotton 
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Machine washable

Pros

  • Exceptional value for two pillows​
  • Good balance between thick and flat
  • 100% cotton for softness and durability
  • Hypoallergenic

Cons

  • No organic designation​
  • Lumpiness concerns after washing
  • No guarantee information

Our favorite feature

If you are looking for great bang for your buck, you'll get an absolute cannon shot with these two quality little pillows. In fact, for the price that you would expect to pay for just one pillow, you will actually receive two of them. And what parent wouldn't appreciate an extra pillow when something unexpected happens!​


Angel Baby Organic Toddler Pillow

Because no child likes to sleep on a hot pillow, this manufacturer combines an organic 100% cotton cover with 75% memory foam filling and 25% polyester fiber filling, resulting in a product that dissipates heat and is extremely breathable.

Each pillow is individually hand-crafted in the USA and offers a Lifetime Satisfaction Guarantee for worry-free purchasing. This product also receives high marks from its online customers for superior quality.

It’s machine-washable and can be used with an optional pillowcase, which is offered at a discount when purchasing this product.​

Best Toddler Pillows

Technical specs

  • Dimensions: 13 x 18 x 4
  • Filling: 75% memory foam, 25% polyester fiber
  • Recommended for ages 2+
  • 100% Cotton 
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Made in the USA

Pros

  • Stays cool and breathable​
  • Organic cover for no chemical exposure
  • Lifetime Guarantee
  • Individually hand-crafted

Cons

  • Not an inexpensive pillow​
  • Surface has plastic-like feel

Our favorite feature

The safety factor cannot be overemphasized when it comes to our children and this product checks all of the boxes in that category. Its organic designation means that your child will be free from exposure to chemicals generated during the manufacturing process, while the hypoallergenic designation virtually eliminates the worry of allergy-causing dust mites.​


Clevamama ClevaFoam Toddler Pillow

Bolstered by scientific data as well as several studies, this manufacturer offers a product with maximum support for a child’s head, neck, and spine. This pillow is more spread out than most other toddler versions, and its thin and breathable design makes for a cool and comfortable night’s sleep. It is also machine-washable and comes with a replacement Airflow toddler pillow cover.​

Best Toddler Pillows

Technical specs

  • Dimensions: 12 x 21 x 2
  • Recommended for ages 1+
  • Memory foam filling

Pros

  • Draws away moisture and increases airflow for comfort and breathability​
  • Proven to protect the round shape of a toddler’s head
  • Larger than most children’s pillows
  • Scientific data back superior ergonomic ratings

Cons

  • Doesn’t fit most toddler pillowcases​
  • No organic or hypoallergenic claim
  • Slight chemical smell when new
  • No guarantee information

Our favorite feature

This is a comfortable, thin pillow that is ultimately designed to improve a child’s comfort and safety. Scientifically proven to protect the unique shape of a child’s head, this product is excellent for keeping moisture to a minimum while staying cool and breathable. In a nutshell, children using this pillow will enjoy many hours of restful, comfortable sleep.​


To find the right toddler pillow for both you and your child, the most important thing to consider is which criteria are the most important to YOU.

If allergies are a concern, a hypoallergenic pillow may be an absolute necessity. If you're worried about your child coming into contact with chemicals during the manufacturing process, finding a pillow that has an organic designation may be the most important item on your checklist.

Perhaps you're looking for a company that backs its product with the best satisfaction guarantee, or one that has the highest customer rating? Or maybe you're looking for the pillow that offers the best ergonomic or economic advantages?

A toddler’s first pillow is an important milestone in her young life. Before you spend a few dollars on this purchase, make sure you spend a few minutes researching some of the options that are available. Only then can you rest assured that you have made the right decision for you and your child. Sweet dreams!​

FUN, delivered straight to your inbox.

Subscribe to the Tiny Fry newsletter and get awesome ideas for spending QT with the little people who make your world go round.